Former Louisville Bishop Accused of Arson Appears in Court Again

LOUISVILLE, Ky. (WAVE) — The case against a Louisville bishop accused of setting fire to his own church has been delayed once more.

Jonathon Mullins appeared in court on April 15 in connection with the 2021 fire that destroyed Greater New Hope Community Church. It has been two years since he was arraigned on arson charges.

Investigators believe Mullins started the fire that burned down the church. He is charged with one count of arson.

The church was located at the corner of South Floyd and East Jacob streets, across from WAVE News. Surveillance footage from a nearby security camera played a role in the investigation.

Since his 2024 arraignment, Mullins has made multiple court appearances, with the case going through several pre-trial conferences and mediation efforts.

During the latest hearing, Mullins appeared without legal representation. Judge Julie Kaelin informed him that a public defender would be appointed unless he hires a private attorney within three weeks.

Prosecutors also requested the appointment of a public defender to help move the case forward.

“This was indicted in March of 2024, we’re two years in and I know the family, the victims they are eager to get this over with. We’ve done mediation, there was an offer outstanding, I think we just need an end in sight,” said Emily Talbott of the Office of the Commonwealth’s Attorney.

Mullins agreed to have a public defender assigned. His next court appearance is scheduled for June 18.

This article has been carefully fact-checked by our editorial team to ensure accuracy and eliminate any misleading information. We are committed to maintaining the highest standards of integrity in our content.